Would anyone be interested in an email group if I can figure out how to start one? (I know it is simple, I've just never done it). I like having the blog, but I'd love to connect and have a two-way conversation about the topic. If you are interested, leave a comment under this post and we'll go from there.
I noticed on my daughter's regular religion chapter this week, the "Call to Faith" book (Harcourt Religion Publishers) heavily waters down one of the Ten Commandments. The Sixth Commandment, "Thou shalt not commit adultery" is explained thusly:
"Be respectful of all people." (I'm paraphrasing because her book is at school now, but it's very close to that. The setup is that they list the Ten Commandments on one side of the table and an "explanation" of that commandment on the other side).
Huh?????
I can't even begin to make the jump there. I told my daughter to just use that answer for school on the test, but to forget it after that. Of course, I can't continuously do that. Then I explained to her what it really means in very simple terms. I think a second grader can comprehend that marriage is meant to be a lasting thing between one man and one woman. They don't even mention marriage in the explanation! Why not? Is it because marriage is under such severe attack these days? The vital cell of society is so unimportant that we can just "skip" that one, meanwhile the child is "old enough" in "whoever-makes-the-decisions-on-the-curriculum's" opinion to learn all sorts of body parts and other such things in a big group-like happy slappy setting without any parental involvement? Hmmm...or could it be that it would not be politically correct these days to insist that marriage and its vows be respected and taught because we might offend someone? We couldn't possible mention that a sin against marriage would be a bad thing. We just need to respect everybody. That's all.
It's so relative of them, isn't it?
My point is, whatever the reasons behind the weak explanation (and perhaps my conclusions are a stretch, but if you're like me, aren't you feeling a little defensive about everything "good" these days?), this Commandment, which ought to be clear and can be easily explained to a child in simple terms, has been heavily watered-down and disfigured and now I realize I really have to be on guard even with the regular religion text.
To explain further why this annoys me so much, I can draw a small parallel. I was watching dear
Father Tom Euteneur on EWTN's "Life on the Rock" last night. He was talking about exorcism and how the devil can tempt us, but was very clear to underscore that the devil only has power over us if we allow it. (In other words, a state of grace is far more powerful and not to fall too hard into being extremely fearful of him. I figured I'd stress it since he did.) And he made a certain point about all the crazy things flying around in this culture that are aimed at desensitizing our children to evil. So, when speaking of, for instance, "Harry Potter"...(sorry to any Harry Potter fans, but we steer clear of Harry Potter in my house), Father begins by stating that clearly the Bible forbids us to mess with witchcraft (my paraphrase) and this is exactly what Harry Potter is all about. And then, playing the devil's advocate (no pun intended), Father talks about the questions a parent might pose in defense of allowing a child to read/see it, "But will the child become possessed by reading Harry Potter?" No, certainly not. "Will the child fall into the practice of witchcraft for reading Harry Potter?" No, not necessarily. But the point is this: These little bits and pieces (and some with more a strong pull than the other) of seemingly benign "you are going too far and making too big a deal about nothing" elements ever-present in today's society, whittle down and water-down the Commandments of God and the fullness of the Faith and do so by
desensitizing (word of the year here) the youth to these awful realities. I think one of the enemy's greatest tricks is to be so subtle, especially in this regard. My first temptation when I notice something that the Holy Spirit has probably pointed out is to say to myself, "you are being a fanatic, that's ridiculous, stop making such a big deal about every little thing!" But I shove it aside if I can. And if it continues to bother me, I send those thoughts right out the door because I realize I am being tempted to drop the topic when it needs to be addressed!
So, am I a making a big deal about this watered down version of the Sixth Commandment? I don't think so. I think it's totally lame and my children are in Catholic school and for goodness sake couldn't we use a better text that is not trying to slowly rob my children of their Faith? I do understand, however, that it is my (and my husband's) influence over them in this matter that will have the greatest power. But I think it is terribly important that my school be cooperating and confirming what I teach at home, not turning the solid beautiful Faith we are trying to pass down into senseless mush.
UPDATE: In discovering a few new articles from St. Joseph's Covenant Keepers, I found this interesting paragraph that may just prove my instinct wrong on the Sixth Commandment. If so, I stand corrected! The Church is wiser than I, so I will look into this further, but wanted to offer it to be fair. Here it is and I link to the two new articles under "Relevant Articles" to the right. "Sex Education: Protecting Your Children from Something Worse than Herod's Troops" and "Flawed Catholic Education". Please read them, they are excellent!
The article states,
"Can morality in sexuality ever be legitimately taught in Catholic classrooms? Yes, but only in a specific way. For almost two thousand years sexual morality has been taught in the course of catechesis. Children and teens were taught the sixth commandment along with the other nine commandments. Yet the Catechism of the Council of Trent along with Pope Pius XI's encyclical on Christian Education urge caution, delicacy, and moderation in teaching the sixth commandment." (from "Sex Education: Protecting Your Children from Something Worse than Herod's Troops", by Steve Wood).
UPDATE #2!!! If I must admit, after reading a little further, I'm kind of confused about the teaching of the Sixth Commandment. It would seem you don't have to talk about "mommy or daddy cheating on eachother", and I can completely comprehend that logic, but not sure if I am correct in finding my daughter's text explanation too vague and watered down....because reading further in Steve Wood's article, he writes (let me be clear, I'm sure he is being clear in his writing, but my brain is not registering on this one)...
"The historically-proven method of teaching sexual morality is simply to teach the sixth commandment along with the other nine. Ditch the sex-ed and chastity programs and teach the third pillar of the new catechism. You will not only save tons of money by not purchasing these expensive programs, but you will save souls from over-exposure to sexuality and sexual immorality." ("Sex Education: Protecting Your Children..."by Steve Wood)